Wins
- Al Spalding… 253
- Tommy Bond… 195
- Bobby Mathews… 167
- Dick McBride… 149
- Candy Cummings… 145
- George Zettlein… 129
- George Bradley… 109
- Terry Larkin… 89
- Will White… 75
- Jim Devlin… 72
- John Ward… 69
- Cherokee Fisher… 57
- Pud Galvin… 41
- Jack Manning… 38
- Tricky Nichols… 27
- Jim Britt… 26
- Jim McCormick… 25
- Asa Brainard… 24
- Bobby Mitchell… 20
- Rynie Wolters… 19
Games Pitched
- Bobby Mathews… 353
- Al Spalding… 347
- Tommy Bond… 321
- George Zettlein… 250
- Candy Cummings… 242
- Dick McBride… 237
- George Bradley… 228
- Terry Larkin… 171
- Cherokee Fisher… 165
- Jim Devlin… 157
- Will White… 131
- John Ward… 107
- Jack Manning… 96
- Jim Britt… 91
- Tricky Nichols… 88
- Bill Stearns… 84
- Asa Brainard… 84
- Jim McCormick… 76
- Pud Galvin… 74
- Harry McCormick… 54
Games Started
- Bobby Mathews… 349
- Al Spalding… 327
- Tommy Bond… 320
- George Zettlein… 244
- Candy Cummings… 241
- Dick McBride… 237
- George Bradley… 222
- Terry Larkin… 171
- Jim Devlin… 153
- Cherokee Fisher… 141
- Will White… 130
- John Ward… 97
- Jim Britt… 91
- Tricky Nichols… 83
- Asa Brainard… 82
- Bill Stearns… 79
- Jim McCormick… 74
- Pud Galvin… 73
- Jack Manning… 62
- Harry McCormick… 54
Innings Pitched
- Bobby Mathews… 3056.3
- Al Spalding… 2890.7
- Tommy Bond… 2866.0
- George Zettlein… 2175.7
- Candy Cummings… 2149.7
- Dick McBride… 2081.7
- George Bradley… 1989.7
- Terry Larkin… 1529.3
- Jim Devlin… 1405.0
- Cherokee Fisher… 1319.7
- Will White… 1175.0
- John Ward… 921.0
- Jim Britt… 816.7
- Tricky Nichols… 745.0
- Bill Stearns… 705.0
- Asa Brainard… 698.7
- Jim McCormick… 663.3
- Pud Galvin… 655.0
- Jack Manning… 572.0
- Harry McCormick… 457.3
Strikeouts
- Tommy Bond… 614
- Will White… 408
- Terry Larkin… 401
- John Ward… 355
- George Bradley… 304
- Bobby Mathews… 303
- Jim Devlin… 273
- Jim McCormick… 233
- Bobby Mitchell… 182
- Pud Galvin… 143
- Al Spalding… 142
- Candy Cummings… 130
- The Only Nolan… 125
- George Zettlein… 115
- Tricky Nichols… 111
- Sam Weaver… 107
- Dick McBride… 106
- Cherokee Fisher… 99
- Harry McCormick… 96
- Frank Hankinson… 73
Walks
- Bobby Mathews… 264
- Dick McBride… 172
- Al Spalding… 156
- George Zettlein… 148
- Tommy Bond… 126
- George Bradley… 119
- Candy Cummings… 117
- Will White… 115
- Terry Larkin… 114
- Jim McCormick… 89
- Jim Devlin… 89
- John McMullin… 79
- Asa Brainard… 78
- Cherokee Fisher… 77
- Bobby Mitchell… 71
- Tricky Nichols… 71
- John Ward… 70
- Jack Manning… 68
- Al Pratt… 61
- Jim Britt… 59
Home Runs Allowed
- Tommy Bond… 39
- Bobby Mathews… 31
- George Bradley… 22
- Dick McBride… 19
- Cherokee Fisher… 17
- George Zettlein… 17
- Al Spalding… 15
- Al Pratt… 12
- Bill Stearns… 12
- Jim Britt… 12
Hit Batters
- Doug Allison… 0
- Ross Barnes… 0
- Jack Manning… 0
- Bobby Mathews… 0
- Dick McBride… 0
- Harry McCormick… 0
- Jim McCormick… 0
- Bill McGunnigle… 0
- Russ McKelvy… 0
- Pat McManus… 0
Saves
- Jack Manning… 13
- Al Spalding… 11
- Harry Wright… 8
- Cal McVey… 5
- Cherokee Fisher… 2
- George Zettlein… 2
- Bobby Mathews… 1
- John Peters… 1
- Ed Pinkham… 1
- Bill Stearns… 1
Losses
- Bobby Mathews… 164
- Tommy Bond… 116
- George Zettlein… 112
- George Bradley… 108
- Candy Cummings… 94
- Cherokee Fisher… 84
- Dick McBride… 78
- Jim Devlin… 76
- Terry Larkin… 75
- Al Spalding… 65
Games Finished
- Jack Manning… 20
- Cal McVey… 12
- John Ward… 10
- George Bradley… 7
- Joe Borden… 6
- Joe Blong… 5
- Amos Booth… 5
- Harry McCormick… 4
- Tricky Nichols… 4
- Cherokee Fisher… 4
Complete Games
- Bobby Mathews… 319
- Tommy Bond… 311
- Al Spalding… 281
- Candy Cummings… 233
- George Zettlein… 228
- Dick McBride… 227
- George Bradley… 208
- Terry Larkin… 169
- Jim Devlin… 151
- Will White… 130
Earned Run Average
- John Ward… 1.92
- Will White… 1.93
- Jim Devlin… 2.05
- Tommy Bond… 2.13
- Al Spalding… 2.14
- George Bradley… 2.26
- Pud Galvin… 2.27
- Terry Larkin… 2.28
- Jim McCormick… 2.29
- Candy Cummings… 2.49
- George Zettlein… 2.78
- Bobby Mathews… 2.80
- Cherokee Fisher… 2.83
- Dick McBride… 2.85
- Tricky Nichols… 2.96
- Jim Britt… 4.38
- Asa Brainard… 4.84
- Bill Stearns… 4.98
WHIP
- Pud Galvin… 1.02
- John Ward… 1.03
- Tommy Bond… 1.06
- Terry Larkin… 1.08
- Jim Devlin… 1.09
- George Bradley… 1.09
- Will White… 1.10
- Al Spalding… 1.19
- Jim McCormick… 1.20
- Cherokee Fisher… 1.22
- Candy Cummings… 1.22
- Dick McBride… 1.25
- Tricky Nichols… 1.25
- Bobby Mathews… 1.29
- George Zettlein… 1.31
- Jim Britt… 1.61
- Asa Brainard… 1.70
- Bill Stearns… 1.74
Hits Per Nine IP
- John Ward… 8.59
- Pud Galvin… 8.77
- Will White… 9.04
- Terry Larkin… 9.09
- Tommy Bond… 9.14
- Jim Devlin… 9.20
- George Bradley… 9.27
- Jim McCormick… 9.63
- Al Spalding… 10.18
- Tricky Nichols… 10.38
- Cherokee Fisher… 10.45
- Dick McBride… 10.46
- Candy Cummings… 10.50
- Bobby Mathews… 10.83
- George Zettlein… 11.14
- Jim Britt… 13.85
- Asa Brainard… 14.26
- Bill Stearns… 15.10
Strikeouts Per Nine IP
- John Ward… 3.47
- Jim McCormick… 3.16
- Will White… 3.13
- Terry Larkin… 2.36
- Pud Galvin… 1.96
- Tommy Bond… 1.93
- Jim Devlin… 1.75
- George Bradley… 1.38
- Tricky Nichols… 1.34
- Bobby Mathews… .89
- Cherokee Fisher… .68
- Candy Cummings… .54
- George Zettlein… .48
- Dick McBride… .46
- Bill Stearns… .45
- Al Spalding… .44
- Asa Brainard… .43
- Jim Britt… .31
Walks Per Nine IP
- Tommy Bond… .40
- Pud Galvin… .44
- Al Spalding… .49
- Candy Cummings… .49
- Cherokee Fisher… .53
- George Bradley… .54
- Bill Stearns… .55
- Jim Devlin… .57
- George Zettlein… .61
- Jim Britt… .65
- Terry Larkin… .67
- John Ward… .68
- Dick McBride… .74
- Bobby Mathews… .78
- Tricky Nichols… .86
- Will White… .88
- Asa Brainard… 1.00
- Jim McCormick… 1.21
Shutouts
- Tommy Bond… 39
- George Bradley… 25
- Al Spalding… 24
- Candy Cummings… 19
- George Zettlein… 13
- Bobby Mathews… 12
- Dick McBride… 10
- Will White… 10
- Jim Devlin… 9
- Terry Larkin… 9