Cutshaw was voted the top defensive second baseman of 1910-20 by the Society for American Baseball Research. He led in putouts five times, assists four times, double plays twice, and fielding percentage three times. He batted cleanup and finished in the top ten in stolen bases seven years in a row (271 career). Cutshaw was tough to strike out, fanning only 10 times in 488 at-bats in 1920.
